Cultural Exchange: Xi Invites 100K Young Americans to China. Should They Go?

-

At his welcoming ceremony hosted by President Trump at the White House on Sept. 24, Chinese president Xi Jinping announced that China would invite 100,000 young Americans to China for study and exchange programs over the next five years.

This was Xi’s second such invitation. In Nov. 2023, when he was in San Francisco for the APEC leaders’ meeting, Xi announced the invitation of 50,000 young Americans to China in five years. Just two years and a half later, according to China Daily, that goal had already been reached.

It was actually in the Seattle area Xi began his idea of such initiatives. On his first state visit to the United States in September 2015, President Xi toured Washington state before flying to Washington D.C. to meet with President Obama. During his visit at the Lincoln High School in Tacoma, Xi invited 100 students to visit China as his guests. The following year, 100 Lincoln High students traveled to China, all-expenses-paid. In fact, a total of 118 students and teachers were on that trip. They toured Fuzhou, Tacoma’s sister city, Chengdu and Beijing.

Now with Xi Jinping’s expanded invitation of “100,000 in 5 years,” what is the reaction?

Fox News sounded alarm, “Xi’s 100K invitation to America’s youth sets off alarm bells over what could follow them home.” It quoted critics warning that Beijing could use the exchange program to spread propaganda, influence a new generation of Americans, and brainwash them while over there.

Washington Examiner called out safety concerns for schools and universities, “Xi wants 100,000 American students in China. Don’t take the bait.” It mentioned State Department warning for Americans to “exercise increased caution” while visiting China due to “the arbitrary enforcement of local laws.”

Defending Education detailed China’s soft-power influence campaigns with such exchange programs with its report “Little Red Classrooms: Young Envoys Scholarship Program,” an update on its 2023 report “Little Red Classrooms: China’s Infiltration of American K-12 Schools.” It pointed out that the Young Envoys Scholarship (YES), the organization carrying out Xi Jinping’s initiatives, was run by China Education Association for International Exchange, which in turn was identified by U.S. lawmakers as part of China’s “United Front,” an agency working to neutralize opposition to the Communist Party.

While safety and influence may be of concern, the cost is probably the first and foremost factor for an American school considering joining such an exchange.

City University of Seattle, a participant of Xi Jinping’s first invitation of 50,000 young Americans, for instance, showed how typically such China tours were paid for in this post of “YES Program Highlights” for the spring trip 2026:

“Location: Hangzhou and Shanghai;
Duration: March 24 to April 1;
Costs: Chinese host covers most program expenses, including accommodations, meals, transportation, and activities.
Participant Costs: Only international health insurance and flights.
Visa Benefits: Participants receive a 5-year F visa, with the visa application fee waived by the Chinese embassy.
Eligibility: Open to the U.S. citizens between 13 to 45 years old, including CityU students, friends, and relatives;
Availability: Only 12 slots — early application is strongly encouraged.”

With their in-country expenses or even all-expenses paid for by the Chinese hosts, 83 American universities and 27 K-12 schools have been documented as participating in China’s YES (Young Envoys Scholarship) program, filling up fast the first 50,000 slots.

But what did these young Americans see in China?

The first group of Lincoln High students to visit China, for instance, toured Tiananmen Square, visited the Forbidden City, and climbed the Great Wall in Beijing, mingled with students at a high school in Fuzhou, and saw pandas up close at the research base of giant panda breeding in Chengdu.

As for the students of CityU of Seattle, they participated in a Cross Border E-commerce & Digital Trade Bootcamp in Hangzhou, given by Zhejiang Financial College, visited Alibaba the company and met its representatives. They also toured Shanghai, including visiting the famous Bund and the Shanghai museum.

Were these young Americans brainwashed while in China?

Hu Ping, Chinese dissident in exile in the U.S., believes so. He said in 2024 that China wanted these American youths to form a positive impression of the CCP rule in China and in turn influence U.S.-China relations and U.S. China policy. He suggested that young Americans invited to China should instead visit the former residence of the late dissident Nobel Peace laureate Liu Xiaobo, the bridge where a man hanged a streamer with anti-Xi Jinping and anti-CCP slogans during the pandemic, etc.

An economics fellow at the Manhattan Institute, Daniel Di Martino, also voiced his dim view of Xi’s new initiative: “This is clearly intended to indoctrinate young Americans in China. But if some people should go, let the DSA members and let them see the Uyghur concentration camps and poor rural villages. Let them speak to the political prisoners. And let them visit and meet Hong Kongers.”

But those young Americans who went to China at Xi’s invitation have their own understanding.

One student from Lincoln High, Rigel Adams told China Daily that he fell in love with the people and the culture in China in 2016. Later, earning a college degree in science and economics, he went back to China six times and visited more Chinese cities. He also hoped to continue building personal and professional relationships, and maybe one day to turn that into a business relationship.

Bates Technical College, of Washington state, also participated in Xi’s initiative. Twenty-two of their students and faculty members went to China in October 2024 and joined an exchange program at Nanjing Vocational University of Industry & Technology. One BTC student expressed how he was fascinated with China’s history and culture, how the camp served as a bridge for communication between Chinese and American vocational schools, and hoped more American students would engage in exchanges in China.

Since President Xi Jinping will probably not rescind his invitation, our young people and their teachers will face this difficult question in the next five years, “To go or not to go?” They shouldn’t.

Instead, the question should be put in front of the U.S. government, the Department of Education, the Department of State, for instance. Instead of having Americans simply oppose China for indoctrinating young Americans with such paid visits, the U.S. government should send its own invitation to young Chinese to visit America for paid study and exchange programs. Instead of having Americans reactively fear China’s influence campaigns, the U.S. government should work on its own counter influence campaigns.

The Manhattan Institute, by the way, could very well be a host for the young Chinese visitors, showing them not just the Metropolitan Museum of Art and the Statue of Liberty, but also the homeless encampment on Manhattan’s West Side, and maybe an ICE detention center, too.


Discover more from Post Alley

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Wendy Liu
Wendy Liu
Wendy Liu of Mercer Island has been a consultant, translator, writer and interpreter. Her last book was tilted "My first impression of China--Washingtonians' First Trips to the Middle Kingdom."

9 COMMENTS

  1. Hmmmm…. I certainly like the idea of inviting Chinese youth to visit USA (though I think so many already have that I’m not sure there would be too much of a point)….. though still it’s not a bad idea…

    But not quite sure I understand why young Americans visiting China is dangerous…

  2. Exchanges and even tourism visits are highly beneficial to both Americans and locals, whether to China or anywhere else. Every trips I’ve made to Europe and Asia, since the age of fourteen when I first went to Europe, has been both interesting and educational to me, and I hope to the many, many local people I went out of my way to talk with. Interacting with others was mutually beneficial, especially in China, where I have travelled three times and where I was able to speak in Chinese with many people, some of whom also practiced their English with me.

    • I can’t agree with you more. Certainly on trip sponsored by a government, students and young people and all visitors should be aware that they are being persuaded… So be it — that’s part of education to think critically.

      So from my travels, I think that America suffers from our vast size and makes it economically difficult for the vast majority of Americans to travel much overseas…. I believe that the American polity would be very different if red state Americans traveled more… (Though I may be talking through my hat since I really don’t have any facts on the blue/red divide vis-a-vis foreign travel…. Would be an interesting statistic to ask Gemini or Claude: “Is there a significant difference in red vs blue populations in terms of foreign travel?”

  3. I’ve just reread this article and I hope the author will elaborate.
    She says that American students shouldn’t go to China to visit. But we in America should invite Chinese students to come to visit us.
    Do you really think that’s practical?
    For one thing, actually forbidding American students from going there will certainly just make it forbidden fruit and make it all the more attractive; plus I’m not sure if the Constitution really allows it, thank God.
    Moreover, wouldn’t such a stance make USA look a little ridiculous?
    Anyway, it’s an interesting subject, and I hope the author will explain a little more. Maybe I am misunderstanding completely.

    • You are not misunderstanding. I think the article author is being xenophobic. I also think your “forbidden fruit” point is well-taken: young people will not be somehow indoctrinated — their thinking will be broadened and they will be naturally critical at the same time they can broaden the thinking and attitudes of the people they meet. Americans in China will actually help Chinese people realize that there is more to the world than the indoctrination the Chinese government imposes on them.

  4. You both misunderstood, completely. I suggested that instead of fearing such visits by young Americans to China paid for by the Chinese government, the U.S. government should invite young Chinese on paid tours to the U.S. also.

    • “Were these young Americans brainwashed while in China?” ” Instead of having Americans simply oppose China for indoctrinating young Americans with such paid visits.” ““To go or not to go?” They shouldn’t.” I don’t think we misunderstood. I think you were trying to discourage young Americans from going to China, but, like a politician, you said so indirectly. Both of us are in favor of both young Chinese coming to the US and young Americans going to China. Also, most readers may not realize that the Manhattan Institute is a right-wing think tank: China is not going to permit young Chinese to visit America to be “indoctrinated” by the Manhattan Institute.

  5. You still misunderstood. I meant that “To go or not to go” shouldn’t be a question facing American students and their teachers. It should be a question facing the U.S. government. Instead of fearing China indoctrinating, brainwashing or influencing America’s young, U.S. should work on its own influence campaigns on China’s young.

    As for the Manhattan Institute, I was sarcastic, because one of its fellows talked about China’s indoctrination and that young Americans should visit poor villages in China. So I suggested that maybe they could host a group of young Chinese and show them the homeless camps in New York.

    • Thanks. Appreciate your response. I’m going to check out other things you’ve written. Esp. like your idea of separating technology from capitalism, a development causing significant problems for both. Noticed you went to McGill and took mathematics: my youngest brother John David Wehrly spent one year studying math at McGill, 1972 I believe.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Comments Policy

Please be respectful. No personal attacks. Your comment should add something to the topic discussion or it will not be published. All comments are reviewed before being published. Comments are the opinions of their contributors and not those of Post alley or its editors.

Popular

Recent