Lots of post-election commentary and analysis over the past few weeks. For my money, one of the most interesting and provocative was an installment in the โInteresting Timesโ series of The New York Times. This one featured Christine Rosen interviewing Catherine Liu, who the Times described as โa left-wing cultural critic and the author of Traumatized: The New Politics of Public Suffering. It is a book I will read.
The interview is titled, โDemocrats Have Power Now. They Shouldnโt Waste It on Woke.โ Subtitle: โThis leftist thinker is skeptical that they can govern without lecturing the country.โ That line would be funny, if it werenโt so true.
Are We Over Identity Politics?
Rosen begins the interview by asking Liu, โWeโve just come out of the midterm elections, a historic transfer of power to the Democratic Party. Are we over identity politics?
Catherine Liu: Iโm afraid not. And I think that there is going to be a lot of resistance to its demise. I also think that there is too much at stake within the NGO industrial complex to wield trauma as a kind of blunt instrument to make elites fall into line.
โI wish I could say that weโre heading toward a more objective, more just, more economically oriented politics on the left-liberal side of things, but Iโve been really shocked at how persistent this kind of identitarianism can be.
โBut I think that weโve turned a corner. I was really, really heartened by the warm language that James Talarico, Gina Hinojosa and even Abdul El-Sayed were able to use. They were not lecturing people. This was a very different kind of campaigning.โ
Liuโs assessment is probably realistic. There are by now a lot of jobs, institutions and programs depending on identitarianism. Still, she is correct to notice that Democrats like Talarico, Hinojosa and El-Sayed all put economic issues and common good, not identity politics, front and center.
The Successful Candidates Ran on Principles
Whatโs more, Liu notes that the successful candidates ran on principles. โThese last elections showed incredible diversity of candidates that succeeded, but they succeeded because they were people of principle who happened to be people of color. And that I was very, very heartened by. They didnโt play the people-of-color card first. They were people of principle.โ
The problems with identity politics are at least two-fold. One, identity politics is inherently divisive. Instead of drawing people together and looking for common ground, identity politics pit one identity group against another. Trump was, of course, very happy to use it for his own ends. Remember โthe deplorablesโ?
The Working Class Family Is Completely Destroyed in America
Second, and in Liuโs view, even more important is that Democrats going hook-line-and sinker on identity politics resulted in entirely missing what was really going on, what has been going on, for Americaโs working class.
Hereโs Liu:
โAll of the sociological studies that have been done by people I really admire, like Jennifer Silva, have shown that the working-class family is completely destroyed in America. If youโre born into a working-class milieu of whatever race, you have more chance of being born out of wedlock than being born to married parents. The rate of divorce is going up in working-class circles in America.
โThese people who are preaching experimentation and all this other stuff โ college-educated women have a much smaller chance of being divorced right now than ever before. College-educated people have very stable relationships.โ
As Iโve noted before, this is the context for understanding the emphasis of many evangelical churches on traditional marriage and family. Sustaining those in todayโs working class world is uphill sledding. Though not, as Trump and some right-wing Christians would have it, because of gay or trans people, but for economic reasons, including the destruction of local economies and cultures, whether by Clintonian neo-liberalism or Trumpist cronyism and greed.
The Working Class Became the Enemy
Many embraced liberal positions on a host of identity and culture war issues while pretty much ignoring the fate of the working class and its precariousness. Under both Democrats and Republicans we have lived for decades now in times of public austerity and private accumulation (see $600K Condos for Classic Cars). The incomes of working people have lost ground as the super-wealthy inhabit realms wholly divorced from ordinary people and life. Worse, the working class became for some enlightened Dems the enemy.
โIn fact,โ argues Liu,โsince 2016, the Democratic Party elites kind of characterized the working-class man โ the working-class white man โ as the enemy of progress. I think that was a terrible, terrible politics and a terrible strategy.โ
Liu tries to understand how identitarianism became so powerful. Her insights dovetail with the excellent recent study of Seattle Public Schools by Sandeep Kaushik, about which I commented earlier this fall. The wholesale embrace of identitarian equity by SPS for a decade had, however well-intended, massive negative results educationally. See my post on โWhen Progressivism Becomes Regressiveโ for more on this.
Whereโs the Love?
But Liu is right that there is hope as many of the newly elected Democrats appear to want America to work for ordinary Americans of all racial and ethnic groups. They arenโt interested in punching down at the working class. They were not talking down to people or, as Liu, put it โlecturing.โ They led with affordability, fairness and decency. They communicated love for America and Americans and not contempt. Good move.
Discover more from Post Alley
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.