87.9 F
Seattle
Sunday, June 26, 2022

Survey Finds Viral Politicization Over COVID Vaccines

Photo by Wesley Tingey on Unsplash

Nearly 80 percent of Americans believe or are unsure of at least one false statement about the COVID-19 pandemic and the vaccines being administered to fight it, according to a new national survey conducted last month by the Kaiser Family Foundation.

The survey reveals the misinformation has become a spreading virus of its own. The coronavirus has killed 755,000 Americans, and more than 5 million people worldwide, but Kaiser’s survey shows that the pandemic has been sucked into the country’s political divisions and that false information is hindering efforts to curb COVID-19.

“Belief in COVID-19 misinformation is correlated with both vaccination status and partisanship, with unvaccinated adults and Republicans much more likely to believe or be unsure about false statements compared to vaccinated adults and Democrats,” the survey of 1,519 American adults concluded.

The country has witnessed viral politicization. The pandemic has provided fodder for late night comics. The beloved Big Bird tweeted last weekend that he had been vaccinated. Big Bird is officially six years old, and spoke as children 5-11 years old became eligible to take a needle in the arm.  But there was immediate angry backlash from sour Sen. Ted Cruz, R-Texas, who Tweeted: “Government propaganda for your five-year-olds.”

Green Bay Packers’ star quarterback Aaron Rodgers has claimed to be a victim of a “woke mob” that wants to “cancel” him, after testing positive for COVID-19. Rodgers had claimed last summer he was “immunized.” Not so. He has been taking ivermectin, a drug generally used to deworm animals that has become popular as a “treatment” against the coronavirus.

“Instead of consulting immunologists, he [Rodgers] consulted anti-vaxxers and podcast host Joe Rogan, who also contracted the virus: Rodgers complained that ‘cancel culture’ was coming for him, but his own words cancel him as a liar and a bad thinker,” wrote NBA hall-of-famer Kareem Abdul Jabbar, who said Rodgers “directly and deliberately lied to fans and the public.”

Although President Trump authorized development of vaccines under “Operation Warp Speed,” the Kaiser poll found that suspicion of vaccines resides in the party of the 45th President.  The poll put out eight false statements about vaccines in its test of opinion. “Nearly one-half (46 percent) of Republicans believe or are unsure about at least half of the statements, three times the share of Democrats (14 percent),” it reported.

The most popular falsehoods: “Three in 10 say they’ve heard that the vaccine has been shown to cause infertility and either believe it (8 percent) or aren’t sure that it’s true.”  (Aaron Rodgers has worried about his ability to sire children. ) Thirty-eight percent believe the federal government is exaggerating the number of COVID-19 deaths. Eighteen percent believe deaths caused by vaccines are being concealed by the government.  Seventeen percent believe it is dangerous for pregnant women to be vaccinated.

The correlation of casualty figures and voting patterns has become pronounced in the late summer-early fall “spike” caused by the Delta variation. Almost 40 percent of Republican adults remain unvaccinated, compared with about 10 percent of their Democratic counterparts.

In October, the Kaiser survey found, 25 out of every 100,000 residents of heavily pro-Trump counties died from COVID-19, more than three times the rate in heavily Biden counties (7.8 deaths per 100,000). “October was the fifth consecutive months that the percentage gap between the death rate in Trump counties and Biden counties widened.”

National findings are echoed by a look at Washington’s experience with the pandemic. While agitation against COVID-19-caused shutdowns was strongest in Central and Eastern Washington, five counties in Trump country experienced the highest percentage of total cases per 100,000 population: Chelan, Yakima, Grant, Benton and Franklin Counties. The Mayo Clinic has kept track of the cumulative number of cases since the pandemic began in March of last year.

Vaccination rates in this state’s 39 counties mirror Kaiser’s national findings.  Five small, conservative and largely rural counties have adult populations less than 40 percent fully vaccinated – Asotin, Garfield, Pend Oreille, Skamania, and Stevens Counties.  The three counties giving strongest support to Joe Biden last November – King, Jefferson, and San Juan – have vaccination rates of 75 to 79 percent.

Kaiser also found a populace influenced by what it watches.  “People’s trusted news sources are correlated with their belief in COVID-19 misinformation,” the survey found. It noted trust in vaccination highest among those watching network news, viewers of CNN and MSNBC, and those watching their local news.

“Larger shares of those who get COVID-19 information from leading conservative news sources believe misinformation, with nearly four of 10 who trust Fox News (36 percent), and One America News (37 percent) and nearly half (46 percent) of those who trust Newsmax, saying they believe or are unsure about at least half of the false statements.” (The most trusted source of information for 49 percent of Republicans is Fox News.)

The Kaiser Family Foundation survey did not specifically indicate whether conservative news outlets were a direct cause of false beliefs about vaccines, or whether misinformed people simply trust these news outlets.

Nonetheless, those who tune in such outlets as Fox News and Sinclair get daily inoculations on the dangers of vaccine mandates, possible danger of inoculating young children – a propaganda specialty of Tucker Carlson – plus sarcastic denunciations of Dr. Anthony Fauci.  Campaigns of misinformation are anchored in the discrediting of experts.

Joel Connelly
Joel Connelly
I worked for Seattle Post-Intelligencer from 1973 until it ceased print publication in 2009, and SeattlePI.com from 2009 to 6/30/2020. During that time, I wrote about 9 presidential races, 11 Canadian and British Columbia elections‎, four doomed WPPSS nuclear plants, six Washington wilderness battles, creation of two national Monuments (Hanford Reach and San Juan Islands), a 104 million acre Alaska Lands Act, plus the Columbia Gorge National Scenic Area.

Post Alley welcomes comments to our articles. Our guidelines: no personal attacks, stay on topic, add something of value to the discussion. Our editors will edit comments for clarity and to conform with our guidelines. We encourage writers to use their full names.

4 COMMENTS

  1. Magic mirror on the wall, “Who do you not trust of them all?”

    Answer: Trust, once lost, is impossible to regain. Sadly, the current inclination is to ‘trust no one’ — an impulse which has become a sign of the times.

    • The leading answer when people are polled about whom do they trust is “people like me.” Accordingly, the best way to convince people about something is to enlist surrogates from a trusted social group. An example is Liz Cheney among Republicans — which may be why there is such a concerted effort to attack her.

  2. The US has fully vaccinated just 58% of its total population and is stalled at that level, which is far too low to silence the Delta variant, let alone what might follow. Vaccinating children will help, but resistance is relatively high along the polarized lines Kaiser revealed. The unvaccinated population in this country is as big as the entire population of a country the size of Italy. The unvaccinated are geographically clustered, which makes it easier for the virus to stay active, burning through them cluster by cluster. Clusters include the above-discussed rural white Republicans, as well as those without health insurance wherever they live. Our national new infections rate is rising again. This time a higher proportion are children, younger adults, and the already-vaccinated. We are likely to experience another winter surge of cases, accompanied by a more modest (but still substantial) surge of hospitalizations and deaths. People are dying at the rate of well over two 9/11s a week, but we’ve become inured to it. It didn’t have to be nearly this bad. It’s a tragedy.

Leave a Reply to David Brewster Cancel reply

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

LATEST

The Stones and Me: Close Encounters with Erratics

2
I like the idea of them as leftovers from the last ice age.  And I like coming upon the objects in places where I don’t expect to find them,

Dark Days: Supreme Court Overturns Roe

12
The U.S. Supreme Court, in its ruling, takes away a right from all Americans. Five Post Alley contributors react.

Jim McDermott: The Good and Bad of Serving in Congress

2
The book is a sharp, spot-on critique of Capitol Hill’s current clumsy dysfunction. Congress used to be collegial, with friendships across the aisle and a transactional culture of accommodating varied interests. No more.

Is America Falling Behind?

2
Visiting our near neighbor reminds this on-edge American that it really doesn’t have to be this way.

For Your Approval: Does Seattle Need a New Way of Electing Its Leaders?

12
Seattle City Councilmembers now have to enact Approval Voting outright or place the issue on the ballot with or without an alternative measure.

TRENDING

The Stones and Me: Close Encounters with Erratics

2
I like the idea of them as leftovers from the last ice age.  And I like coming upon the objects in places where I don’t expect to find them,

Dark Days: Supreme Court Overturns Roe

12
The U.S. Supreme Court, in its ruling, takes away a right from all Americans. Five Post Alley contributors react.

The Complicated Legacy of Julia Child

3
The show may be a fictionalized version of Child’s groundbreaking TV success, but it portrays struggles by women for recognition and equality that ring true to that era.

Jim McDermott: The Good and Bad of Serving in Congress

2
The book is a sharp, spot-on critique of Capitol Hill’s current clumsy dysfunction. Congress used to be collegial, with friendships across the aisle and a transactional culture of accommodating varied interests. No more.

The Supreme Court: Republican Majorities Since 1970

10
In fact, in every year since 1970, the majority of Supreme Court justices have been Republican appointees. Since the beginning of Chief Justice Warren Burger’s court until the death of Justice Ruth B. Ginsberg, there have been 31 Republican appointed-justices and 8 Democratic appointed-justices sitting on the Supreme Court.The Supreme