57.4 F
Seattle
Tuesday, September 17, 2019

Impure Thoughts: Nukes Versus Climate Change?

The invaluable (and Seattle-based) national reporter on environmental issues, David Roberts, displays the advantage of disaggregating an issue that bedevils our political debates. Here in Vox, he takes apart the discussion on nuclear energy. He also points to the way Jay Inslee’s nuanced climate proposals (analyzed in this earlier Post Alley post by Eileen Quigley), live on in the positions of other candidates (particularly Elizabeth Warren) who remain in the presidential sweepstakes (discussed in Carol J Williams’ Post Alley piece here).

Roberts says there are three different questions to be answered. First, should existing nuclear plants in America be given extended lives? (Yes, he says.) Second, should we build more conventional nuclear plants? (No: not economically viable or politically possible.) Third, what about next-generation, lower-waste plants, such as the small nukes Bill Gates is backing? (Unclear if these will get approved or built, but yes, spend a lot on this research.)

The discussion has become “tribal,” a way of signalling virtue. (Example A: Bernie Sanders has a pure no-nukes stance, as does Elizabeth warren.) After all, the anti-nukes movement was present at the birth of environmentalism and remains a core dogma. Rather than purity tests, Roberts argues, better to have complex answers to the separated problems.

Makes one wonder how this analytical approach could be applied to other knotty, potentially tribal issues such as homelessness and affordable housing.

Image by Catalania Catalino from Pixabay

David Brewster
David Brewster, a founding member of Post Alley, has a long career in publishing, having founded Seattle Weekly, Sasquatch Books, and Crosscut.com. His civic ventures have been Town Hall Seattle and FolioSeattle.

1 COMMENT

  1. I’m against relying on nuclear energy in any way unless we can foist off any waste into space. Didn’t know Bill Gates was promoting small nukes. David Roberts should stick to writing about the Holy Land as did his predecessor.
    Disaggregating is one hard word for me, though I love to take things apart so will use it as often as I can interject it into my daily conversations.
    Keep dry. CS

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

LATEST

Books: A New Classic of Northwest Logging and Radicalism

If Norwegians and Swedes laid down the legends of the Puget Sound country, Finns were their counterparts in southwest Washington and northwest Oregon in lands drained by the mighty Columbia.

Seattle Elections: Has the “Movement Left” Reached Its Half-Life?

Interest groups have a half-life of about 30 years in the fluid, non-partisan world of Seattle politics.

Democrats’ Debate: Let a Little Sunshine In

The best thing you can say about Julian Castro’s taunting of Joe Biden about “forgetting what he...

The Great Realignment: Are You Ready For America’s Seventh Version Of Political Parties?

We live in historic times. Our system is being realigned as a seventh party system firms up. Republicans have chosen long term political suicide by alienating everyone other than their increasingly narrow base. The door is open for the Democrats.

Dem Debate: A House Divided?

With so many threats to American security and democracy that every one of the 10 candidates was able to plant his or her flag on a vital issue.

TRENDING

Seattle Elections: Has the “Movement Left” Reached Its Half-Life?

Interest groups have a half-life of about 30 years in the fluid, non-partisan world of Seattle politics.

Books: A New Classic of Northwest Logging and Radicalism

If Norwegians and Swedes laid down the legends of the Puget Sound country, Finns were their counterparts in southwest Washington and northwest Oregon in lands drained by the mighty Columbia.

Dynamic Duo: When Maggie And Scoop Made The Senate Work For Us

Jackson and Magnuson each established a formidable legislative record. When it came to getting bills passed in Congress, these senators would put today’s Congress to shame.

The Great Realignment: Are You Ready For America’s Seventh Version Of Political Parties?

We live in historic times. Our system is being realigned as a seventh party system firms up. Republicans have chosen long term political suicide by alienating everyone other than their increasingly narrow base. The door is open for the Democrats.

Blown away by an unfiltered Mayor Pete

Simple outcome. I was blown away. Twenty minutes of house party stump speech was even better than I had any reason to guess I would come away with. Answers to questions were even better.