47.6 F
Monday, November 18, 2019

“No Matter What You Say, Republicans Are Going To Call You A Socialist.” So What Are You Fighting About?

The “Battle” in Detroit (screen grab)

Have to say – I hated the CNN open – “FOUR CANDIDATES FROM THE HEARTLAND… READY TO DO BATTLE…BERNIE AND ELIZABETH AT THE PROGRESSIVE EDGE READY TO BATTLE…” Could they make it any more like a prize fight? The combatants enter the arena one by one. And then… presentation of the colors? The national anthem?… I know our institutions are teetering, and I am Canadian, after all, but really, is this wallow of patriotism really necessary? And then, full juices flowing we’re ready for… a quick cut to a commercial break. Talk about crappy alienating television. Ugh. It’s a full 13 minutes in and the candidates have yet to speak.

Ten candidates is a lot. Hard to spend much time with any of them to develop ideas. That said, I liked this format more than the first Miami debates. Moderators addressing one candidate but including a second and letting them talk to one another was better than doing one at a time then descending to free-for-all. The candidates were also slightly better behaved in not talking over one another.

It was set up as a battle between moderates and the progressive side with Marrianne What’s-Her-Name playing the outsider, almost like one of us on the outside, chiding the Dem party for not doing things. She’s still too woo-woo, but she got some good shots in. Obvious three or four of them won’t still be around by the September debate. Gone by then: Bullock (his aw-shucks folksiness didn’t play well), Ryan (he blended into the wallpaper), Delaney (who got beat up in the health care portion), and probably Hickenlooper (Gee I had a good time!). That takes a bite out of the moderate clutter.

While the health care portion at least took on the central policy issue: scrap the current system and start over or build on what we have and give people options, the climate portion was disappointing. The fact that it was relegated to the deep middle part of the evening and that there weren’t really hard questions belied the urgency the issue is due.

Takeaways: Nobody really moved the needle. No disasters or gaffes, no big victories. No real surprises. And here’s CNN at the end, hyping the “clash of ideas,” and congratulating candidates on “scoring some good hits” and trying to shape it as a prize fight. Pretty tiresome.

Postscript: Favorite moment is Anderson Cooper interviewing Williamson afterwards and she’s explaining that politics has fallen behind the rest of American society. He’s clearly flummoxed, fascinated, charmed. He says her name was most-searched online tonight during the debate. No kidding. She got off a couple of sidewinder speeches calling for the need for love and a call for a moral revolution. She’s not like the others and she plays a counterpoint to the politicians on the stage and to the journalists.

Douglas McLennan
Douglas McLennanhttps://www.artsjournal.com
Doug is a longtime arts journalist, and the founder and editor of ArtsJournal.com, he's frequent keynoter on arts and digital issues, and works with a number of arts organizations nationally.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


After Day One: Failure To Move The Needle

While everybody here is pretty much on the mark for the way they and people in the liberal bubble saw and reacted...

Enough Stress Already!

Our system wasn’t designed to tolerate this level of partisan stress.  A system based on checks and balances, and dependent...

What Did the Optics Know, And When Did They Show It?

Republicans were simply out-gunned and forced to reach beyond the facts of the case in search of rebuttals. Their turn to the dramatic—the histrionics and posturing of Jim Jordan of Ohio—only reminded us of the weakness of the GOP bench, at least on this committee.

Pass Me The Subpoena Colada! And an Essay Book.

While incarcerated McDowell has been given a writing assignment by the judge. He is to write four essays on the following topics: “Finding Meaning in Life Other Than Committing Crimes,” “Principles of the Declaration of Independence and How Your Behavior Undermines Them,” “Importance of Respecting the Rule of Law,” and “Importance of Respecting Property Rights.”

Opening Salvo: The Patriotism Card

The Democrats running the House impeachment hearings are shrewdly playing the patriotism card, hoping that a patriotism narrative will displace the partisanship...


13 Things You Can Do About Climate Change

There are a variety of actions you can take to get on a path to a lower personal carbon footprint and work toward ensuring a lower carbon future.

Intiman: The Theatre That Wouldn’t Die

One of Seattle's primary theatres dodges a bullet and soldiers on. The question is should it?

Blown away by an unfiltered Mayor Pete

Simple outcome. I was blown away. Twenty minutes of house party stump speech was even better than I had any reason to guess I would come away with. Answers to questions were even better.

After Day One: Failure To Move The Needle

While everybody here is pretty much on the mark for the way they and people in the liberal bubble saw and reacted...