#3. Puget Sound Crab Populations are Flourishing


Back in August, boaters in my neighborhood near Port Townsend decided to throw a community crab feed.  Over a few days, they caught and cleaned and cooked more than 150 Dungeness crab, iced them down in a dinghy and treated some 250 friends and family.

It’s been that kind of year for local crabbers. While Northwest biologists and policy makers try to deal with diminished stocks of salmon and other finfish, crab seem to be doing just fine – at least in northern areas from Port Townsend to the San Juans, where more than 90 percent of Salish Sea crab are generally harvested.

Rich Childers, who managed crab fisheries at the state Department of Fish and Wildlife (WDFW) before retiring to Port Townsend, recalls when Puget Sound crab harvests ranged from two to four million pounds annually in the 1990s.  Over the past 15 years, catches have averaged nearly 10 million pounds.

This despite heavy fishing all summer by treaty tribes, commercial crabbers and up to 240,000 recreational fishers, who pay $8 to add crab to their state fishing licenses.  Navigating a small boat out on Townsend Bay during July and August becomes an obstacle course, zigging and zagging to avoid snagging somebody’s crab line.  By mid-summer, local crabbers are filling their freezers and begging neighbors to take their excess catch.

Why are crab prospering while salmon aren’t? No one knows for sure.  Banning bottom trawls, which drag huge nets across the sea bottom, probably helped. But for all their efforts, biologists acknowledge that Puget Sound remains a black box, where crab eat and get eaten in an impossibly complex ecosystem. 

That said, scientists have a number of theories, or educated guesses, among them:

Adult males only:  For many years, the basic management strategy has been to limit the season while requiring crabbers to keep only large males.  All females and smaller males (shells measuring less than 6 1/4 inches across) must be thrown back.

That strategy dates back decades to when crabbing was driven by San Francisco buyers, Childers says.  “Fishermen were told: Don’t bring in any females, and no males smaller than a dollar bill, because they don’t sell.  And that became the management strategy that continues today.”

So more than half of the crab captured are thrown back to reproduce and perhaps be caught another day.  That works well with the crab life cycle.  Mature crab grow mostly in spurts timed to their annual molting, when they wriggle out of their old shells and quickly grow new ones.  “It’s amazing,” Childers says. “They’ll grow an inch and a half in a very short period of time.”  A five-inch crab immediately absorbs water and becomes a six-inch crab, while the six-incher becomes 7 ½.  It’s a form of delayed gratification; Throw back today’s smaller crab and you’ll get a bigger one next year.  And the females go back and reproduce.

Predation: Who eats whom?  Like most fish, crab are stunningly productive.  A mature female will produce from 1 million to 2.5 million eggs per year. The hatched larvae drift with ocean currents, where the vast majority – more than 99 percent — are eaten by something larger. 

And the predators include salmon.  As salmon runs dwindle, there are fewer fish eating larval crab, so more larvae survive to reach maturity, Childers says. 

Do crab traps feed crab? Crabs are harvested with a simple device called a crab trap – a disc or box roughly two by two feet by one foot deep, made of two-inch steel mesh that resembles a chain-link fence. The trap is baited with fish heads or chicken legs or (in my case) freezer-burned meats from neighbors’ basements.  There is a one-way door on each side, hinged at the top, allowing hungry crab to crawl in for the bait.  The larger crab can’t get out, but smaller critters wander in, feast on the bait, then leave through the two-inch mesh or a couple of larger four-inch “escape ports.”

Biologists believe that baited crab traps have become significant “feeding stations” for females and smaller crab.  “Think about it,” Childers explains. “There are thousands of traps out there, each one baited, pulled and rebaited every day for the season.  When people pull the traps, they throw the old bait back in the water….  That’s a lot of food.”

Whatever the reasons, the summer crab fishery appears to have been successful in northern waters, says Don Velasquez of State Fisheries.  The recreational season closed on schedule after Labor Day, giving the state time to assess stocks.  But regulators expect that it will be reopened October 1. 

Ross Anderson
Ross Andersonhttps://rainshadownorthwest.com/
Ross Anderson is a founding member of the Rainshadow Journal collective. He retired to Port Townsend after 30 years of journalism at the Seattle Times.


  1. Thanks, Ross, great information! As a Port Townsend crabber it seems to me that there were fewer pots out this year in Port Townsend Bay I don’t know why that would be, but I have sometimes been discouraged by the chronic poaching problem that has persisted for years—losing both crabs and pots to the poachers.

  2. what a beard?!
    Hi Ross.
    You don’t really answer the second question: why are salmon doing so badly? A scientific paper published in 2020 concludes that a huge percentage of silver (coho) salmon exposed to a chemical that exists in all our tires, and is therefore in the stormwater, are killed. Next story?

  3. I think Puget Sound wild coho may actually be more numerous in recent years, though. No expert at untangling all the reports, so I could be missing something. Not meaning to contradict the tire chemical issue, which is real.

    The general picture though is complicated. “Ocean conditions.”

    There’s a huge pink salmon population with hatchery support, that may be driving down the numbers of other species, as at the age of a year or two old out in the ocean they’re going after some of the same prey, and vastly outnumber chinooks etc.

  4. The salmon are falling; due to lack of federal and state regulations and control of native practices and catches.
    I have personally seen how they are destroying our wild runs by catching females with eggs and not releasing- keeping the eggs; netting across the whole river- instead of letting some by. Keeping everything.
    So they kick up their native hatcheries, and kill off the wild runs; to corner the fish population (returning to hatcheries-not up river).


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Comments Policy

Please be respectful. No personal attacks. Your comment should add something to the topic discussion or it will not be published. All comments are reviewed before being published. Comments are the opinions of their contributors and not those of Post alley or its editors.