55.6 F
Seattle
Saturday, July 2, 2022

Study: ‘Progressive’ Cities Worsen School Achievement Gaps

Discovery Institute, Seattle’s conservative think tank started by Bruce Chapman, has a program looking at education reform. Don Nielsen, formerly on the Seattle School Board, is program chair of the effort, the American Center for Transforming Education.

ACTE just highlighted a new study showing that achievement gaps between minority and majority students are considerably higher in progressive cities, including Seattle. It duly notes that this does not prove causation; nor is it a result of income disparities. The study also finds that conservative cities have significantly lower achievement gaps in schools.

Nielsen observes, “The problem is the system…All kids can learn. However, some are far better prepared than others and they get support along the K-12 continuum. Treating them all the same does not take that into account and, therefore, the system fails the ill-prepared.” It’s an interesting insight into the new directions for education reform, coming from the right. One wonders about the costs of such a tailored program, and if conservatives would be up for such a bill.

David Brewster
David Brewster
David Brewster, a founding member of Post Alley, has a long career in publishing, having founded Seattle Weekly, Sasquatch Books, and Crosscut.com. His civic ventures have been Town Hall Seattle and FolioSeattle.

Post Alley welcomes comments to our articles. Our guidelines: no personal attacks, stay on topic, add something of value to the discussion. Our editors will edit comments for clarity and to conform with our guidelines. We encourage writers to use their full names.

3 COMMENTS

  1. Another factor I would suggest is the potency of labor unions in progressive cities, and such teachers’ unions can be opposed to education reforms, as well as to charter schools. Many cities that register gains in educational outcomes are factoring in students at charter schools. Bloomberg’s claim about improvement in racial gaps in New York City may reflect the high number of charter schools in that city.

  2. Bailey Takas concludes the ACTE study referenced, “At ACTE we aim to transform the education system. In a broad view, our approach is to change an adult-focused system to a student-focused system; change an input-focused system to an output-focused system; change a teaching-focused system to a learning-focused system; change a group-focused system to an individual-focused system; and change a time-focused system to a competency-focused system.” This what another Seattle native has done [Delivering on the Promise: The Education Revolution] and is doing in Russia. [https://annmichaelsen.com/2020/01/24/changing-72-000-schools-in-russia/] In parallel,
    ‘Patient-centered|Outcomes-based’ care is the foundation for healthcare system change as well.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

LATEST

Time to Lower the Heat in the Post-Roe Commentary

4
If the SCOTUS decision is the beginning, not the end, of the debate, we will need a lot more thoughtful commentary. Here are some examples.

Bolting for the Bigs: USC, UCLA Abandon PAC-12 for Big Ten (UW Next?)

12
It’s official now that the industry has fallen off the edge of the flat Earth propped so long by the mythology of amateurism.

Inside City Hall’s Serious Budget Shortfall

7
The multimillion-dollar gap -- viewed in the perspective of an annual budget in the $7 billion range -- is perhaps not horrific. But it still is bound to impact what the city can achieve towards meeting its on-going needs and ambitious social goals.

Battling Cancer, B.C. Premier Horgan to Step Down

1
Horgan, leader of the New Democratic Party, was a temperamental opposition leader but has proven an avuncular head of government. 

Pot Industry Versus its Workers

2
A new political action committee, People for Legal Cannabis, is gearing up to fight any effort by outsiders such as the UFCW to empower their workers. 

TRENDING

Bolting for the Bigs: USC, UCLA Abandon PAC-12 for Big Ten (UW Next?)

12
It’s official now that the industry has fallen off the edge of the flat Earth propped so long by the mythology of amateurism.

Time to Lower the Heat in the Post-Roe Commentary

4
If the SCOTUS decision is the beginning, not the end, of the debate, we will need a lot more thoughtful commentary. Here are some examples.

Inside City Hall’s Serious Budget Shortfall

7
The multimillion-dollar gap -- viewed in the perspective of an annual budget in the $7 billion range -- is perhaps not horrific. But it still is bound to impact what the city can achieve towards meeting its on-going needs and ambitious social goals.

The Complicated Legacy of Julia Child

3
The show may be a fictionalized version of Child’s groundbreaking TV success, but it portrays struggles by women for recognition and equality that ring true to that era.

The Fallacy (and Laziness) of Both-Sides-ism

2
The Republicans and the Democrats are not the same. Underlying too much of contemporary reporting is a “false equivalency,” which posits that by representing “both sides” balance and objectivity are attained.