37.6 F
Seattle
Saturday, April 4, 2020

Is Seattle Courting Over-Tourism?

Image by Ed Judkins from Pixabay

Blockbuster shows at art museums are becoming impossible crushes, and museums are struggling to figure out strategies. The same holds true for cities such as Venice and Paris, where the plight of over-tourism may lead to bans on cruise ships and other ways of restricting (and monetizing) access.

Seattle has a version of this indigestion. Summer is already crammed with visitors, made worse when cruise ships arrive and disgorge. Places like the Pike Place Market are now so crowded in fair weather that surveys show many locals are staying away. Yet there are plans to add a third cruise-ship terminal, designed for extra-large ships (6,000 passengers) who would inundate the south waterfront and Waterfront Park.

When cities invest in the visitor market (hotels, convention centers, festivals) they are ordinarily playing a final, desperate card in economic development. Such jobs are seasonal, low-paid positions. Restaurants and retailers that cater to tourists, rather than repeat customers, raise prices and lower standards. The economics touch off a non-virtuous circle where convention centers demand more hotels, hoteliers overbuild and demand more conventions.

There was a time when downtown Seattle panicked over the loss of retail anchors such as Frederick & Nelson and the flight of retail to suburban locations, and demanded more visitors. The city responded by nabbing Alaskan cruise ships and expanding our awkwardly sited convention center. Now tourists drive away regular, local customers.

Once we felt differently. When the Seattle Art Museum was building its first phase downtown, it notably lacked large rooms for blockbuster shows. The argument from local art collectors was that these crowded shows degrade the contemplative experience of viewing art, and those folks who come for the blockbuster shows are expensive to convert into regular members. Now SAM depends heavily on visitors, many of them wandering in from their visit to the nearby Pike Place Market. With funding for the arts in decline, it’s natural that these museums are getting more addicted to the revenues from blockbusters.

We are well down this slippery slope of over-tourism. One way to put on the brakes is to tell the Port there are much better uses for Pier 46, just south of the Ferry Terminal, than building a mega-cruise-ship terminal.

David Brewster
David Brewster, a founding member of Post Alley, has a long career in publishing, having founded Seattle Weekly, Sasquatch Books, and Crosscut.com. His civic ventures have been Town Hall Seattle and FolioSeattle.

3 COMMENTS

  1. Overtourism is a real worry over our quality of life—but the real danger of cruise ships is the heavy diesel fuel they use. Exhaust from cruise ships are a Group 1 carcinogen along with asbestos and tobacco smoke. (Source: National Cancer Institute https://dceg.cancer.gov/research/public-health-impact/diesel-exhaust-cancer-risk). There is substantial and growing scientific evidence that cruise ships are incredibly harmful for the environment and for human health. Seattle and the Port will talk about the tourist dollars that a new cruise ship terminal will mean for Seattle, without any mention of the real cost of such a program.

  2. Overtourism and carcinogenic sulfur oxide exhaust will have mortality effects in Pioneer Square and anywhere near these cruise ships. Electrifying the waterfront may mitigate the air quality issue some, but the carbon emissions from cruising (3-4X higher than air travel) will make it that much harder for our city, nation, and world to meet climate goals established by the IPCC. Australia is burning down now, the oceans and atmosphere are cooking. If you care about these issues, please attend the next Port of Commissioner’s meeting on January 7, at Pier 69 on the Seattle waterfront at 12 noon. Come by 1145am if you intend to offer public comment. https://www.facebook.com/events/550663415665232/

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

LATEST

The View From 2023: How Seattle Changed

The Virus Depression (called VD) has greatly changed the way we live. Surveillance mechanisms are now ubiquitous, monitoring temperatures, spacing, coughing. Grocery stores are well-policed, both to enforce health regulations and to guard against the food riots that broke out in late 2020.

“We Shall Beat It On The Beaches, We Shall Beat It On TV” – Trump’s COVID Oratory Through Our Churchill Spinometer

Never in the field of human conflict was so much owed by so many to me, and me alone. Only I can fix this.

Coronavirus Chronicles: Unexpected Shortages of Sudden Needs

Just try to buy a solid looking buzz clipper. Sold-out, sold-out, sold-out. Now I did find one for way too much money, and it won’t arrive for a while. I will be cautious about Zoom meetings.

A Bridge Too High? How Warren Magnuson Overbuilt The West Seattle Bridge

Maggie drained the entire $100 million bridge replacement fund and soon the bridge design was high enough to allow passage of "the highest mast conceivable for a ship at that time; higher than has ever been remotely needed."

Running for Office When the World is Shut Down: How One Candidate Is Adapting

For candidates running in the time of pandemic, whether it’s Joe Biden seeking to unseat Donald Trump, or a 37-year-old Seattle woman seeking office for the first time, the playbook of how to get elected has changed in ways nobody ever envisioned.

TRENDING

“We Shall Beat It On The Beaches, We Shall Beat It On TV” –...

Never in the field of human conflict was so much owed by so many to me, and me alone. Only I can fix this.

The View From 2023: How Seattle Changed

The Virus Depression (called VD) has greatly changed the way we live. Surveillance mechanisms are now ubiquitous, monitoring temperatures, spacing, coughing. Grocery stores are well-policed, both to enforce health regulations and to guard against the food riots that broke out in late 2020.

A Bridge Too High? How Warren Magnuson Overbuilt The West Seattle Bridge

Maggie drained the entire $100 million bridge replacement fund and soon the bridge design was high enough to allow passage of "the highest mast conceivable for a ship at that time; higher than has ever been remotely needed."

Why Hasn’t Washington Adopted Ranked Choice Voting?

FairVoteWA, the citizens group urging adoption of the system, urged the state Democratic Party to use it in its multi-candidate March 9 primary, but for unexplained reasons it declined, even though its 2018 platform calls for its adoption, presumably statewide.

West Seattle Bridge Cracks Explained

Since bridges are generally over-engineered, small cracks usually don’t add enough stress on their own to cause further cracking. But combined with the external forces that created the crack in the first place at some point they lead to progressively larger cracks. Then the stresses start accumulating on the part of the concrete that is still intact as the load shifts, and the process accelerates.