50.3 F
Seattle
Wednesday, November 13, 2019

Democrats’ Debate: Let a Little Sunshine In

The best thing you can say about Julian Castro’s taunting of Joe Biden about “forgetting what he had just said” (which he hadn’t) is that it is good preparation for dealing with Donald Trump. Trump will be taunting whoever the nominee is with everything in his pathetic arsenal. So good practice for Biden, should he be the nominee.

Still, it seemed to me a pretty cheap shot by Castro (especially since he was wrong about what Biden said). It sounded like age-ism to me. “Did Uncle Joe forget his keys again?”

Otherwise, it seems like the field of ten all came across pretty well. Each one is beginning to have a clearer persona. When responding to the final question on “resilience” (which I suppose could be considered a softball), I found most all of the candidates convincing and admirable.

I have been more impressed with Elizabeth Warren than I expected to be. She is strong and focused. But I’m with those who want to take a more reformist approach here and build on Obamacare. The Democrats have not had good luck going for the biggest and best on health care.

Amy Klobuchar and Cory Booker are looking to me like good VP candidates on a Biden ticket. Probably Klobuchar would have the edge there as she brings with her a midwest base and possibly more midwest states than her own Minnesota.

I liked Beto’s, “Yes, I will take your AR-15’s and AK-47’s.” But until he had the El Paso shooting to build on, as he did in each of his moments last night, it was unclear what he was bringing to the race. I still think he’s in over his handsome head here, but do wish he had defeated Ted Cruz and landed in the Senate.

While everyone was watching Biden to see if he would show signs of being too old I would say that it was Bernie who probably aroused more suspicions of being out of gas. He seems to have only one modulation to his hoarse voice. That gets tiresome.

Recently I surveyed Republican Never-Trumpers to get advice for the Democrats. Peggy Noonan had suggested that since Trump is dedicated to grim and dark, maybe the Democrats could be a little sunnier and take a more positive outlook on the nation.

Problem is that most of the liberals and progressives have bought into a narrative that racism is at the core of America and explains everything about us. There’s no doubt that racism is real and that our history is stained with racist laws and terrorism. But if you make that the central narrative, as many on the left now have, it makes it difficult to say much positive about the country.

I agree with Noonan that the Democrats would do well to remind us of our better angels and capacities, as Klobuchar and Buttigieg attempted to do last night. But if the narrative is that racism is the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth, that will overshadow themes about America being hopeful and seeing positives in the country.

My general experience as a leader is that you’re more likely to get people to tackle hard stuff by reminding them of their strengths and capacity for goodness than by telling them how awful they are.

Anthony B. Robinson
Anthony B. Robinsonhttps://www.anthonybrobinson.com/
Tony is an ordained minister of the United Church of Christ. He is the author of thirteen books, including the best-selling Transforming Congregational Culture and the award-winning What’s Theology Got To Do With It: Convictions, Vitality and the Church. He is a frequent contributor to The Christian Century as well as other publications. He writes for the “The Daily Devotional” of the United Church of Christ. He has served four congregations, most recently Seattle’s Plymouth Congregational Church, UCC.

1 COMMENT

  1. I would add that Beto’s confiscation line, while it brought down the house, is a fatal problem for the rest of the Democrats. The guilt-by-association will infect all the others. Democrats have always been careful not to be knocking on doors and taking away guns. Rather: ban purchases and buy back guns (maybe even forced buy-backs with a deadline). Crossing that line may well sink Beto from further ascent in the Democratic hierarchy.
    I also think Mayor Pete has now provided the best succinct statement of medical insurance, short of socialized medicine: Medicare for all who want it. The man has a way with framing, moving the discussion to trusting individuals to make their own choice. Expecting people after Trump to trust government to come up with a grand scheme for medical insurance is poor timing.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

LATEST

Intiman: Theatre Of The Future? (an update on the “theatre that wouldn’t die”)

The existential question is what exactly Intiman is at this point. The speed at which money has been raised so far suggests there's still a constituency willing to find out, but the Big What is still an open question.

The Sounders Lift Our Spirits. Let Me Count the Ways.

For millions of short or average height—like me—this is such a refreshing change from the super-bulked athletes of professional football or the towering giants of basketball.

Trump Could Win in 2020, but the GOP Is Losing Suburbs and Sinking Fast

That national Republican suburban collapse is driving politics here too. Since Trump became the face of the GOP, Republicans have lost 12 seats in Olympia, and one seat in Congress, all from suburban districts. That is likely to continue next year.

The Michael Bloomberg Lane: Is There One?

The billionaire ex-mayor of New York City isn't done thinking about being president. Post Alley writers think about that.

Books: A Seattle Historian on How the West Rescued a Starving Russia

I was shocked by this story — it was so dramatic, moving, powerful, and historically important — yet few Americans, and even fewer Russians know about it.

TRENDING

Intiman: Theatre Of The Future? (an update on the “theatre that wouldn’t die”)

The existential question is what exactly Intiman is at this point. The speed at which money has been raised so far suggests there's still a constituency willing to find out, but the Big What is still an open question.

Seattle Arts Organizations Say They’re Leaders For Social Justice. So Why Are They Fighting...

It's illuminating that the argument Seattle's arts organizations are making isn't about whether paying overtime is fair, but whether it's affordable.

Trump Could Win in 2020, but the GOP Is Losing Suburbs and Sinking Fast

That national Republican suburban collapse is driving politics here too. Since Trump became the face of the GOP, Republicans have lost 12 seats in Olympia, and one seat in Congress, all from suburban districts. That is likely to continue next year.

The Sounders Lift Our Spirits. Let Me Count the Ways.

For millions of short or average height—like me—this is such a refreshing change from the super-bulked athletes of professional football or the towering giants of basketball.

A Better (And Fairer) Way To Fund Medicare For All.

What employers now pay for their workers’ health insurance should be paid NOT to the government but to the workers as a raise – both the portion already taken out of employee paychecks and the company’s share.