50.3 F
Seattle
Wednesday, November 13, 2019

No Debate Allowed!

I had a note from a reader last week about an event that had been scheduled for Ballard’s Peddler Brew Pub but which was cancelled under pressure.

The idea of the event at Peddler was for people across the ideological spectrum to discuss homelessness in Seattle. One of the participants was going to be Christopher Rufo, a documentary film maker for PBS, who doesn’t buy the group-think that rules Seattle on this issue.

Here’s an excerpt from Rufo’s Facebook post about the cancelled event:

“I was scheduled to participate in a public discussion at Peddler Brewing about ‘Seattle Is Dying’ with representation from across the ideological spectrum. But rather than participate in the conversation, local activists bullied and threatened the owners of the brewery, who caved under pressure and canceled the event.

“This is what’s happening in our city. We’ve created an ideological monoculture that prevents the robust public debate our city needs. We have ceded the public square to bullies who want to avoid accountability for their failed policies and intimidate anyone who brings new ideas into the conversation.”

Subsequently, I did a little looking on-line and found more about and by Rufo. He had announced a run for City Council a year ago, but threats and harassment, directed against him, his wife and children, caused him to withdraw.

Early this year Rufo was featured in a pod-cast done by City Journal. It is well worth listening to (runs 15 or 20) minutes. Rufo describes Seattle policy making on homelessness as “ideologically driven.” The podcast references a longer City Journal article by Rufo titled, “Seattle Under Siege.”

So there are two issues here. One is shutting down debate that doesn’t fit with conventional views about the nature of homeless and possible solutions to its challenges. Turns out our famously tolerant Seattle isn’t at all tolerant when it comes to deviations from the left of center orthodoxy.

The second issue is the “presenting” one. What to do about a growing problem. Rufo lays out some steps that make sense to me. Incidentally, they are fairly similar to an op-ed I did for the Seattle P-I in the 90’s titled, “Zero Tolerance for Homeless.” I argued then for sufficient shelter beds for everyone who needed one, and when that existed, not allowing encampments here, there and everywhere. Since then the problems have gotten much worse.

There’s a sense in which I wonder if Seattle isn’t actually “using” the homeless, even as at least some of the homeless use Seattle.

By that I mean the issue provides a way to posture and virtue-signal, without getting around to actual problem solving. And it has spawned what Rufo and others call “the homelessness industrial complex,” agencies and programs whose budgets grow as the homeless population does. Sort of a dis-incentive to make progress!

Currently, as Rufo points out, in the Puget Sound region a billion dollars is spent annually ($80,000 per homeless person) on a problem that isn’t showing much sign of getting better.

In the article Rufo describes four approaches to homelessness in Seattle. I’ll let you read them for yourself, but for this one. One that may fit some of us in the church. This he calls “The Compassion Brigade.” For these folks compassion is the highest, indeed the only, value. The problem with this approach is that it pays attention only to inputs (food, blankets, shelter, medicine and services) but not outputs, i.e. is anyone getting better or on the path to health and greater independence. In this sense, compassion may make those who deliver  it feel good, but without actually doing good.

Rufo’s points are similar to those raised in the Eric Johnson KOMO documentary, “Seattle Is Dying,” which aired in March. It was widely attacked as right-wing “propaganda.” After some kerfuffle, it has been largely ignored.

Another angle in this has been City Attorney, Pete Holmes, and his childish vendetta against the head judge of Seattle’s Municipal Court, Ed McKenna. McKenna had the temerity to suggest Holmes policy of ignoring petty (and some not so petty) crime was contributing to the problem.

In nature a “mono-culture” isn’t a healthy environment (think those large swatches of just alder or cottonwood trees and nothing else).

The same is true of a political mono-culture. That’s what we have in Seattle. A political mono-culture with activists who resort readily to intimidation, personal attacks, threats of violence and public shaming. None of this bodes well for the city’s future.

Anthony B. Robinson
Anthony B. Robinsonhttps://www.anthonybrobinson.com/
Tony is an ordained minister of the United Church of Christ. He is the author of thirteen books, including the best-selling Transforming Congregational Culture and the award-winning What’s Theology Got To Do With It: Convictions, Vitality and the Church. He is a frequent contributor to The Christian Century as well as other publications. He writes for the “The Daily Devotional” of the United Church of Christ. He has served four congregations, most recently Seattle’s Plymouth Congregational Church, UCC.

1 COMMENT

  1. “He had announced a run for City Council a year ago, but threats and harassment, directed against him, his wife and children, caused him to withdraw.”

    The story is a bit more complicated than that. Also, during your “looking on-line” did you see what his followers are doing to Erica C. Barnett on Twitter?

    Pretty disappointed to see such a one-sided post here.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

LATEST

Intiman: Theatre Of The Future? (an update on the “theatre that wouldn’t die”)

The existential question is what exactly Intiman is at this point. The speed at which money has been raised so far suggests there's still a constituency willing to find out, but the Big What is still an open question.

The Sounders Lift Our Spirits. Let Me Count the Ways.

For millions of short or average height—like me—this is such a refreshing change from the super-bulked athletes of professional football or the towering giants of basketball.

Trump Could Win in 2020, but the GOP Is Losing Suburbs and Sinking Fast

That national Republican suburban collapse is driving politics here too. Since Trump became the face of the GOP, Republicans have lost 12 seats in Olympia, and one seat in Congress, all from suburban districts. That is likely to continue next year.

The Michael Bloomberg Lane: Is There One?

The billionaire ex-mayor of New York City isn't done thinking about being president. Post Alley writers think about that.

Books: A Seattle Historian on How the West Rescued a Starving Russia

I was shocked by this story — it was so dramatic, moving, powerful, and historically important — yet few Americans, and even fewer Russians know about it.

TRENDING

Intiman: Theatre Of The Future? (an update on the “theatre that wouldn’t die”)

The existential question is what exactly Intiman is at this point. The speed at which money has been raised so far suggests there's still a constituency willing to find out, but the Big What is still an open question.

Seattle Arts Organizations Say They’re Leaders For Social Justice. So Why Are They Fighting...

It's illuminating that the argument Seattle's arts organizations are making isn't about whether paying overtime is fair, but whether it's affordable.

Trump Could Win in 2020, but the GOP Is Losing Suburbs and Sinking Fast

That national Republican suburban collapse is driving politics here too. Since Trump became the face of the GOP, Republicans have lost 12 seats in Olympia, and one seat in Congress, all from suburban districts. That is likely to continue next year.

A Better (And Fairer) Way To Fund Medicare For All.

What employers now pay for their workers’ health insurance should be paid NOT to the government but to the workers as a raise – both the portion already taken out of employee paychecks and the company’s share.

The Sounders Lift Our Spirits. Let Me Count the Ways.

For millions of short or average height—like me—this is such a refreshing change from the super-bulked athletes of professional football or the towering giants of basketball.