Endangered Species: Editorial Cartoonists


Last Sunday, David Horsey drew a cartoon showing a cartoonist beset by bean counters and hedge fund execs. In an accompanying essay in the Seattle Times, Horsey declared that political cartoonists have now become an endangered species. Besides a feeling of dread, the thought drew me back to the unsettled days when I was (nominally at least) David’s boss.

It started on a spring day in 1981 when Seattle Post-Intelligencer Publisher Virgil Fassio made a rare appearance in the newsroom. He was there to deliver a bombshell: the news that the P-I was seeking a joint operating agreement (JOA) with its long-time rival, the Seattle Times Company.

Days later, the paper’s editorial page editor, Jack de Yonge, announced he was leaving the P-I to head an Alaska Statehood study. That left me, the assistant editorial page editor, serving as “acting” editor. The interim job stretched to two years as we awaited approval of the controversial JOA by the U. S. Department of Justice.

With the unexpected title came responsibility: putting out seven editorial pages a week, working with two overworked editorial writers and a novice cartoonist, David Horsey. Not long out of the University of Washington’s School of Communications, Horsey had convinced de Yonge to hire him as the P-I’s cartoonist in 1979. The way it worked: Horsey would bring de Yonge a rough draft of a cartoon, leaving final inking until he had the editor’s approval.

After I stepped into de Yonge’s oxfords, we followed a similar routine. Most of the time, there was no problem. Reagan was in the White House and Horsey would often draw the president flirting with ideas like tax cuts, perhaps depicted as a seductive young woman. After seeing Horsey’s rough drawing, I might only suggest he dress the temptress more appropriately for a family newspaper.

Other than showing too much cleavage, Horsey’s other problem was when he flew too close to the publisher’s sacred cows by making fun of Mariners’ ownership or the Seattle business establishment. Each afternoon we’d take page proofs to the publisher’s office and sometimes I’d get a phone call: no hello or identification, just a growl saying I should pull the cartoon as too insulting to the Chamber of Commerce or whatever. I’d usually manage to convince Fassio that Horsey wasn’t anti-business and that cartoons, by definition, always exaggerate.

While Horsey adjusted to barriers, he also took advantage of any chance to get away by way of various summer overseas opportunities, educational grants, and seminars. That left the edit page faced with either using the dreary crop of Hearst cartoonists or finding a substitute for the summer. On a couple of occasions, I lucked out, often with a student from the UW Daily. Among them was Howie King, who had a unique comic style. Howie was working on an education degree and later would become a school administrator and play in a band. Another brilliant find from the Daily was Mike Luckovich, who today is a Pulitzer Prize-winning cartoonist at the Atlanta Constitution.

However, one substitute didn’t work out. I forget his name but not his crime. I hadn’t watched closely enough to keep him from drawing an Israel fighter dropping bombs on Palestinian women and children. Somehow the cartoon got picked up to fill a hole on the op-ed page. The next morning, the editorial office was jam-packed: overwhelmed by angry members of the  Jewish community.

To assuage their rage, it took a self-flagellating editorial disavowing the cartoon as not based on reality and a goodbye to the fledgling cartoonist. Cartoons typically offend someone, but there are lines that shall not be crossed. (A former P-I edit page editor had discovered that when she ran a syndicated Paul Conrad cartoon showing then President Nixon being nailed to a cross.)

Those were days when almost every major newspaper had a staff cartoonist. Sad to say that is now only a distant memory. In last Sunday’s column, Horsey noted that in July alone, the McClatchy chain laid off three Pulitzer-prize-winning cartoonists in a single devastating day (Jack Ohman of the Sacramento Bee, Kevin Siers of the Charlotte Observer and Joel Pett of the Lexington Herald-Leader). Contrary to a subsequent mealy-mouthed news release lauding their work, the three cartoonists were dumped mainly because the hedge fund put profits above the community journalism it dishonestly professes to serve.

Political cartoonists are merely the easiest budget item for numbers crunchers to target. Not that there aren’t other targets in the incredibly shrinking newspaper world. Opinion pages are one such area. Gannett, the nation’s largest chain with 200 papers including the much-shrunken Bellingham Herald, said last year it would offer opinion pages “only a couple of days a week.” The “Letters to the Editor” feature, blamed for requiring much staff time, has also been wiped out by many papers.

The dwindling number of editorial cartoonists speaks loudly to our increasing inability to find humor in political life and our unwillingness to see more than one side to issues. In his Sunday essay, Horsey acknowledged the obvious truth that an editorial cartoon is guaranteed to anger someone. Yet, he argued that “publishers who stick by their cartoonist are wise enough to know that an outraged reader is an engaged reader.” Horsey calls them “anti-fans,” the readers “who disagree but stick around to see the next lamebrained, ignorant image that we produce.” (Horsey’s latest cartoon collection – his ninth — is titled “Drawing Apart: Political Cartoons for a Polarized America”)

Never mind that Horsey once drew an unflattering cartoon of me; David still is my favorite editorial cartoonist, treasured both for his wit and his excellence at caricature. Who else can so deftly capture the former president — lumpy, orange-faced, mop-haired, squinty-eyed and bloviating? Thanks to you, David, and to the dwindling number of cartoonists who continue to gift us with chuckles and insights. May you continue to stay afloat in these fraught times and keep us smiling.

Jean Godden
Jean Godden
Jean Godden wrote columns first for the Seattle Post-Intelligencer and late for the Seattle Times. In 2002, she quit to run for City Council where she served for 12 years. Since then she published a book of city stories titled “Citizen Jean.” She is now co-host of The Bridge aired on community station KMGP at 101.1 FM. You can email tips and comments to Jean at jgodden@blarg.net.


  1. Editorial cartooning figured in two of the most hilarious moments of my tenure at what one writer nicknamed “the last of the madhouse newspapers.”

    The most feature most hated by readers and staff of the Seattle Post-Intelligencer was the Sunday (ghostwritten) column of William Randolph Hearst, Jr., which was required to run on the front page.

    When Spain’s dictator Generalissimo Francisco Franco died, Hearst was one of the few people to mourn the old fascist’s passing. Franco had brought order to Spain and been a bulwark against communism in the western Mediterranean. On that Sunday, however, Hearst’s column jumped to an inside page with a cartoon by Paul Conrad of the LA Times.

    It showed the hooded figure of the Grim Reaper leading Franco away, with words of Hemingway: “Do not ask for whom the bell tolls: It tolls for thee.” The paper apparently reached Hearst in a period of sobriety. He did not appreciate the Spanish Civil War reference, and there was hell to pay. Conrad was banished — for a time.

    The construction of the Tacoma Dome was a matter of great civic pride in the City of Destiny. David Horsey did a drawing, however, on how the Dome could reflect the spirit of the city. A chimney on the roof belched pollution into the sky. The sign outside advertised topless dancers, truck pulls and “Wrasslin’.”

    The cartoon struck civil nerves. We took incoming fire from the editor of the News Tribune, the president of the News Tribune Co., the Pierce County Executive, the Mayor of Tacoma, the head of the chamber of commerce.

    David Horsey came to work late that morning, with an angelic smile on his face. He knew exactly what the response would be, and walked up to the beleaguered edpage editor and cheerfully asked: “What’s happening?”

  2. LOVE these stories! Let’s read about some other cartoonists who served our region, including Brian Bassett (Seattle Times, fired, if I recall, by Editorial Page Editor Mindy Cameron), Tony Auth (The News Tribune), and Thomas Whittemore (I do not recall which outlet, but I have one of his originals on my wall).

  3. The cutting of editorial columnists has been going on for years. Virtually all left, like the three recent McClatchy cartoonists, have won Pulitzers, the competition has grown so thin. Some, like Horsey, have two. In almost all cases, the editorial cartoon was the only thing for which most readers went to an editorial page, Horsey not excepted. Dropping them by those who have is just plain dumb. But it relieves publishers of having to explain to those whose feelings have been hurt that maybe the problem isn’t the cartoonist.

  4. I blush at your words, Walter; but please know I loved even the difficult times at both newspapers,. the reason we got paid so modestly was that we’d have paid to get to work there and the bosses knew it.
    As for the City Council I’m forever grateful to the voters for giving me a chance to do some good and lasting things for us all. It all took longer to fruition than we thought. Plans we made for the Waterfront for instance only now paying off.

  5. Au contraire, Mme. Godden. I’ve found that editorial cartooning is alive and well.

    One of my favorite Friday media experiences is the weekly “Cartoon Carousel” on Politico. Even though that site clearly leans left, Politico shows as many cartoons skewering “Bidenflation” and cancel culture as they do Trump’s legal woes and MAGA buffoonery, as well as other stuff like Putin, Macron, Elon Musk’s ego, and so on. A recent week’s example: https://www.politico.com/gallery/2023/08/25/the-nations-cartoonists-on-the-week-in-politics-00112796?slide=0

    Longtime cartoon blogger Mike Peterson also posts a daily review of editorial cartoons on the trade site The Daily Cartoonist. He does critique the messaging on the selected cartoons, which does reveal his leftish bent, but he does give props to conservative cartoons that convincingly make their cases. Recent example: https://www.dailycartoonist.com/index.php/2023/09/02/csotd-political-potpourri-2/

    Peterson also critiques the daily comic strips, which apparently are still a thing, and nonpolitical single-panels: https://www.dailycartoonist.com/index.php/2023/08/29/csotd-how-we-learn-or-dont/

  6. BTW, I attended a David Horsey presentation at a Barnes & Noble years ago, promoting his new editorial cartoon collection titled “The Fall of Man”. During his talk a guy asked, “Why didn’t you call it ‘The Fall of Man and Woman’?”, apparently because females are as guilty of society’s shortcomings as males are. Horsey replied that readers would figure out that “man” was a synonym for “mankind” or “humankind”, and that the title wasn’t (necessarily?) male-bashing.

    The grump turned around and left. Horsey paused, gave us a “What’s his deal?” look, and continued his presentation.

  7. Howie King graced the UW Daily after David Horsey left the paper as editor. I’ve often thought of his wacky style since. It was a passable wake up paper for the early classes. A favorite go to was the aroma de Tacoma, which was a real thing up until the late 70’s or shortly after. Thanks for the brief words on his fate.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Comments Policy

Please be respectful. No personal attacks. Your comment should add something to the topic discussion or it will not be published. All comments are reviewed before being published. Comments are the opinions of their contributors and not those of Post alley or its editors.