Where’s the Beef? Patty Murray’s Campaign Ads Omit her Significant Record


We weren’t buzzed by a rattlesnake, but a hike in the Hanford Reach of the Columbia River some years ago left everyone covered waist-to-feet with cheatgrass.  Sen. Patty Murray, D-Wash., was in her trademark tennis shoes, seeking to show off land she hoped that President Clinton would soon designate a monument under the Antiquities Act.

Murray is still in the world’s greatest deliberative body.  After 30 years, she wants to stay there.  A onetime Shoreline preschool teacher, Murray finds herself being pummeled by Republican opponent Tiffany Smiley. Murray is depicted as a “professional politician,” no longer the “mom in tennis shoes,” and the ads blame her for just about every societal problem save for wheat rust.

Smiley is getting around and gaining ground by claiming Murray does nothing for the state. The claim is a lie, but the senator’s campaign has underplayed her accomplishments.  The Murray folk set out early to define Smiley as an anti-abortion extremist, and they have stuck with this approach after a successful primary election. A well-coached Smiley has learned to slide off excesses of MAGA Republicanism.

My favorite image of the incumbent is one of Murray with feet on the ground in blue jeans, trooping through corners of Washington proposed for preservation or development.  She delivered on Hanford, the last un-dammed stretch of Columbia River and spawning grounds for the river’s last big wild salmon run. Also, she guided creation of the 106,000-acre Wild Sky Wilderness in Snohomish County, even getting blessing from the Bush Administration.  She midwifed additions to the Alpine Lakes Wilderness and protection of the Middle Fork-Snoqualmie River, closest mountain valley to Seattle.

A snarky evaluation of Congress in Washingtonian magazine once derided Murray’s attire and gave her a “no rocket scientist” award.  It missed the mark on both counts.  Fashion is an encumbrance when you’re in the rain and mud visiting where three forks of the Snoqualmie River come together.  And Murray is possessed of unusual smarts, an instinct for the right time and path to get something done.

The prints from Murray’s tennis shoes show up in a variety of places.  Remember when Sound Transit’s light rail service to the airport was going to terminate in Tukwila?  As a power on the Appropriations Committee, Murray fought for money to take it to Sea-Tac (and now beyond). With schools stifled by testing requirements of the Bush administration’s No Child Left Behind law, Murray and GOP Sen. Lamar Alexander teamed up to successfully rewrite the law.  

With control of Congress split, and Murray chairing the Senate Budget Committee, she negotiated a spending agreement with House budget boss Paul Ryan that kept the federal government open. Ovarian cancer was topic of the “Gentle Lady’s” first Senate speech, evoking the health struggles of friends.  She has spent three decades fighting to boost research dollars for diseases impacting women.

It helps to know how to work the levers.  Although slowed by diabetes in his last term, Sen. Warren Magnuson found a legislative vehicle (the obscure Marine Mammals Protection Act) to sneak through a “little amendment” that banned oil supertankers from Puget Sound. That provoked Gov. Dixy Lee Ray into calling Maggie “a dictator.”

When the 2000-01 Seattle newspaper strike turned nasty, Murray found a topnotch federal mediator who helped settle it.  The Seattle Times editorial page has since endorsed Republicans for the Senate but has stood by Murray.  (It likely helps that publisher Frank Blethen is a fellow WSU graduate.)

After the Oso landslide, arch-conservative colleague GOP Rep. Doc Hastings asked how to help communities cut off by closure of S.R. 530.  Murray suggested preserving the lookout atop Green Mountain, a major draw for hikers. Doc made it happen as chairman of the House Natural Resources Committee.  That maneuver set the stage for cooperation on Alpine Lakes and Middle Fork. Doc was rewarded with an amendment securing Tri-Cities folk continued road access to the top of Rattlesnake Mountain.

The Murray record is missing in this year’s consultant-driven campaign.  Nasty TV spots win elections, and our airwaves are filled with scripted hit pieces.  We no longer have a competitive Northwest news corps to sort out the work horses (such as Murray) and show horses of Congress. 

Murray is a member of the Senate’s Democratic leadership.  She is also 72 years old. A protective cocoon tends to surround senior U.S. Senators, particularly in times when a slipup or open microphone can end a career.  It became impossible to get a schedule out of Murray’s office, and difficult to find non-staged events, during my last years at SeattlePI.com  “Thank you for reaching out,” the press office would respond, and then stonewall the request.

A Bellingham attorney called last week, riled at the Murray campaign asking for money after a long absence of communication.  He had once raised money for Murray, an easy task given that she was around and accessible, with a savvy aide in Everett troubleshooting watch on the northwest corner of the state.

My benchmark is the Pacific County Democrats’ crab feed, longest continuous political event in Washington until the COVID-19 pandemic.  Delicious eats, speechmaking, plus an old-fashioned action.  Sen. Maria Cantwell spooned out potato salad in the food line while U.S. Rep. Derek Kilmer plunked crabs onto plates.

Murray never showed up and didn’t send a statement for a couple of years.  By contrast, with a Monday stop-off in her bus tour, Tiffany Smiley paid her fourth visit to Pacific County.  My bet is that she’ll carry this historically Democratic county, which once went for George McGovern.

I voted for Murray and hope she survives.  Why? Because she delivers for folks who work hard and play by the rules, and who love the outdoors.  Lately, she helped with legislation that caps insulin costs for seniors, and (finally) allows Medicare and Medicaid to negotiate drug prices with Big Pharma. The anti-Murray TV spots are paid for largely by those who have reaped Republican tax cuts in this new Gilded Age.  Republicans aren’t into capping drug costs.

I also hope to see Murray emerge from the cocoon.  Win or lose, she will hopefully put on tennis shoes to celebrate one more environmental achievement: The Senate is (one hopes) set to pass Wild Olympics legislation.  The senator and staff need to do more reaching out, from misty Pacific County to dry places with cheatgrass.

Even though she has the prime Senate floor seat behind Majority Leader Chuck Schumer, Patty Murray remains rooted here. She’s a Coug.

Joel Connelly
Joel Connelly
I worked for Seattle Post-Intelligencer from 1973 until it ceased print publication in 2009, and SeattlePI.com from 2009 to 6/30/2020. During that time, I wrote about 9 presidential races, 11 Canadian and British Columbia elections‎, four doomed WPPSS nuclear plants, six Washington wilderness battles, creation of two national Monuments (Hanford Reach and San Juan Islands), a 104 million acre Alaska Lands Act, plus the Columbia Gorge National Scenic Area.


  1. Of course Patty is a Democrat, but unlike some commentators, I do not feel there is something evil at being a good honest — not election denying — member of the other party. Recall that Patty did indeed work with the GOP’s Paul Ryan to solve a budget crisis. She also managed to pass some 39 bills thru the Senate during her terms, a record setter I believe. Some politicians are content to pass just one bill during a political career. The work she has done on health care, veteran’s issues and women’s rights is astounding. She IS that workhorse.

  2. “Remember when Sound Transit’s light rail service to the airport was going to terminate in Tukwila? As a power on the Appropriations Committee, Murray fought for money to take it to Sea-Tac”

    Hey Joel — Sound Transit’s press release announcing that extension project says Sound Transit’s existing revenue sources paid for it, not any appropriation from Patty Murray:


    Light rail goes to airport: ST, Port of Seattle, City of SeaTac announce major agreement
    Publish Date December 21, 2004

    Sound Transit, Port of Seattle and the City of SeaTac today announced a plan for extending light rail service directly to Sea-Tac International Airport by December 2009. … Sound Transit outlined a financial plan for covering the estimated $225 million cost of the light rail extension relying entirely on existing revenue sources. The Port of Seattle has financial capacity for the airport and roadway improvements that will enable the light rail extension.


    Is her campaign for this reelection saying Murray appropriated federal grant funds to cover the Airport Link costs? That’d be wrong.

  3. Tiffany Smiley blames Patty Murray for crime in Seattle, scary brown people coming across the Mexican border and calls Social Security and Medicare “handouts” fueling inflation. Even if any one of those scare tactics was true, which they are not, what on earth could a political novice and MAGA apologist do to change our problems? She would just hand the Senate majority to Republicans who would scuttle her one defensible policy, support for veterans, to Rs who call that “handouts.” Murray has done more for our state’s military community than Smiley could or would do as McConnell’s kingmaker.

    • Sen. Murray’s quiet and sober demeanor, quietly pushing through veteran’s issues, women’s rights, education bills, championing health care workers …. is a welcome relief from the shrill rhetoric on the right. Sen. Murray is also, as others have noted, a negotiator.Anyone who thinks that isn’t a useful talent when passing legislation is naive. But it’s astonishing, frankly, that Tiffany Smiley could get as far as she has.

  4. “Smiley is getting around and gaining ground…”

    Uhh…sure she’s gaining ground. She’s only gonna lose by 8 points instead of 13.

  5. I am enthusiastically for Murray. I think she has been an effective and remarkable Senator. I can’t imagine someone who has done so much for Washington being defeated. I have voted for her in each of her elections and find her record in support of our state excellent.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Comments Policy

Please be respectful. No personal attacks. Your comment should add something to the topic discussion or it will not be published. All comments are reviewed before being published. Comments are the opinions of their contributors and not those of Post alley or its editors.