Handicapping State Elections: Blue Tide Rising


Baseball and politics are both a game of numbers.  Just as you can look at the historical performance of the players on the Mariners’ roster and project that they are going to be terrible again this year, you can look at some basic political numbers and project that Washington state will continue to move towards one-party Democratic rule in 2020.

Being a Republican in Washington has never been easy, but Republicans had been able to occasionally elect Governors, Senators, and Attorneys General, and cobble together majorities in the state House and Senate.  In 2015, Republicans had a slim majority in the state Senate, and were two seats away from a tie in the House. Then came Trump.

Since Trump became the face of the GOP, Republicans have lost five Senate seats and seven House seats in Olympia, and, for the first time ever, the 8th congressional district.  Trump has turned Washington deep blue by driving away suburban voters in droves.  And two sets of numbers indicate that trend will continue in 2020.

  • In the January Crosscut/Elway poll Democrats outnumber Republicans by a margin of 41% to 24%; and D’s lead in the generic ballot test for the legislature 52% to 35%.   These margins are at historical highs.
  • Trump only received 37% of the vote here in 2016, and since then his approval rating has dropped by 28%.  Today 62% of Washington voters disapprove of Trump’s performance, while only 35% approve.

Facts are stubborn things, and the fact is that when your party is this far underwater what you do as an individual candidate means very little.  In other words, Republicans in Washington state are toast in 2020 unless something HUGE happens to change the national trajectory.

This reality means that there is no need to waste much time analyzing this year’s top of the ticket state race.  Unless a well-known Democrat unexpectedly decides to run against the Governor, Jay Inslee will be easily and comfortably reelected.  In fact, the bizarre decision by Tim Eyman to run as a Republican means the Governor’s “race” will hurt down ballot Republicans. Voters in competitive districts will be reminded repeatedly that the GOP is the party of Trump, AND a guy who steals office furniture. 

Likewise, every statewide and congressional Democratic seat is safe this year.   There are several freshman Democratic legislators who flipped Republican seats in 2018 who would normally be considered vulnerable, but at least for now, any D who won in 2016 or 2018 should be considered a heavy favorite.

This leaves only two interesting questions regarding the 2020 elections in Washington state.  First, will Democrats take even more seats away from Republicans? And second, what path will the civil war in the Democratic party take?  Will moderates lose primary challenges?

Jaime Herrera Beutler

At the top of the Democrats’ list is defeating Republican Rep. Jaime Herrera Beutler in southwest Washington’s 3rd congressional district.  Democrat Carolyn Long received 47% of the vote against Herrera Beutler in 2018 and has already raised over $1 million for the rematch. Trump won this district by 23,000 votes, so Herrera Beutler has the edge unless the blue wave grows even bigger.

Democrats will also try and unseat Republican state Treasurer Duane Davidson, and Secretary of State Kim Wyman.  Davidson won in 2016 because too many Democrats got in this race and two Republicans advanced to the November election.  This time he is facing Democrat Rep. Mike Pelliciotti from Federal Way. Given the partisan tide it seems likely the Democrats will flip this office.  

Wyman has also drawn a tough opponent in Seattle Rep. Gael Tarleton, but Republicans have not lost a Secretary of State race since 1960 (!) and Wyman won comfortably in 2016.  The D tide would have to rise very high to beat Wyman.

Turning to Olympia, four Republican Senate seats appear vulnerable:

  • In the 10th district (Skagit/Island counties) Republican veteran Barbara Bailey is retiring and Democrats flipped a House seat here in 2018.
  • Sen. Lynda Wilson (17th district, Clark County) could be threatened given how close the Democrats came to winning a House seat in this district last election. 
  • Puyallup’s 25th district Senate seat will be open because Sen. Hans Zeiger is running for the Pierce County Council. Democrats barely lost both House races here in 2018.
  • Senator Steve O’Ban has won several tough races in Lakewood’s 28th district, but his district is clearly trending away from the GOP.  D’s won both House races here comfortably in 2018.

And in terms of the state House, Republicans will be defending nine vulnerable seats they won with less than 53% of the vote in 2018:

  • Rep. Norma Smith, 10th district (Island/Skagit)
  • Rep. Vicki Kraft, 17th district (Vancouver)
  • Rep. Larry Hoff, 18th district (Clark county)
  • Rep. Jim Walsh, 19th district (Cowlitz county and the coast)
  • Both seats in the 25th district (Puyallup)
  • Rep. Jesse Young, 26th district (Gig Harbor)
  • Rep. Drew MacEwen, 35th district (Shelton)
  • Rep. Luanne Van Werven, 42nd district (Whatcom county)

While Democrats appear poised for even more gains in 2020, in what direction is their party headed?  There is undeniably a civil war going on in the party between the Sanders/progressive/Democratic-Socialist wing, and the Biden/establishment/moderate wing.  

Across America, and here at home, primary battles are brewing. In the 10th congressional district race to replace retiring Rep. Denny Heck, a democratic socialist, Joshua Collins, is facing off against several more establishment Democratic politicians.  Representatives Zack Hudgins and former Speaker Frank Chopp have already drawn primary opponents, and rumors out of Olympia indicate more primary challengers may be on the way. As the Republican party shrinks, will the real battles in our state soon be between the two factions of the Democratic party?

That’s how election 2020 looks today. We will check in again after candidates formally file for office in May.

Chris Vance
Chris Vance
Former Washington State Republican lawmaker and State Party Chairman. Republican nominee for the US Senate in 2016. Now an independent.


  1. The anticipated tussle between two factions of the Democratic Party may well come to Washington state quite soon. Assume that a Democrat wins the White House and that Gov. Inslee nabs a good federal job and vacates the governorship. A race for a new governor (once Lt. Gov Habib is replaced as interim) would touch off a serious contest. All three likely candidates (Hilary Franz, Bob Ferguson, Dow Constantine) are broad-based. Which of them (or someone new) will try to occupy the Biden lane? (I assume the GOP will have great difficulties in fielding a serious candidate.) I foresee the same struggle for Seattle Mayor, assuming Mayor Durkan also is lured away by a federal post.

  2. BS! Democrats and Republicans are sick of the endless taxes. Our legislators and Governor do not listen to the voters. Why would we reelect them?


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Comments Policy

Please be respectful. No personal attacks. Your comment should add something to the topic discussion or it will not be published. All comments are reviewed before being published. Comments are the opinions of their contributors and not those of Post alley or its editors.